By Louis Jacobs
ISBN-10: 0511557361
ISBN-13: 9780511557361
ISBN-10: 0521263700
ISBN-13: 9780521263702
ISBN-10: 0521269482
ISBN-13: 9780521269483
This booklet, the single one in English which may function a textbook for novices and extra complex scholars of the Babylonian Talmud, examines intimately a couple of commonplace long passages in an effort to displaying how Talmudic reasoning operates and the way the Talmud used to be compiled by way of its ultimate editors. The publication serves as an advent to the character of this attention-grabbing paintings on which the Jewish brain has been intellectually encouraged and nourished for over 1500 years. unique insights into the Talmudic debates are supplied for the glory of Talmudic specialists however the paintings is meant mainly as a consultant to scholars who desire to receive a greater than superficial proposal of what the Talmud relatively is ready.
Read or Download The Talmudic Argument: A Study in Talmudic Reasoning and Methodology PDF
Similar sacred writings books
Download e-book for kindle: The Passionate Torah: Sex and Judaism by Danya Ruttenberg
During this specific choice of essays, a few of modern day smartest Jewish thinkers discover a huge variety of primary questions with a view to stability old culture and glossy sexuality. within the previous couple of many years a few factors—post-modernism, feminism, queer liberation, and more—have introduced dialogue of sexuality to the fore, and with it an entire new set of questions that problem familiar traditions and methods of considering.
Head, Eyes, Flesh, and Blood: Giving Away the Body in Indian - download pdf or read online
Head, Eyes, Flesh, and Blood is the 1st accomplished learn of a primary narrative subject in premodern South Asian Buddhist literature: the Buddha's physically self-sacrifice in the course of his past lives as a bodhisattva. engaging in shut readings of news from Sanskrit, Pali, chinese language, and Tibetan literature written among the 3rd century B.
Read e-book online Text-Critical and Hermeneutical Studies in the Septuagint PDF
Text-critical and Hermeneutical experiences within the Septuagint is the identify of a bilateral learn undertaking performed from 2009 to 2011 by way of students from the schools of Munich (Germany) and Stellenbosch (South Africa). The joint examine firm used to be rounded off by means of a convention that happened from thirty first of August - second of September 2011 in Stellenbosch.
- Praying the Book of Job (Praying the Scriptures (Destiny Images))
- The Sutra of Queen Srimala of the Lion's Roar and the Vimalakirti Sutra
- Scholastic Magic: Ritual and Revelation in Early Jewish Mysticism
- The Path of Purification: Visuddhimagga
Extra resources for The Talmudic Argument: A Study in Talmudic Reasoning and Methodology
Example text
Judah's views as recorded (a) in a Baraita and (b) in a Mishnah (Gittin 7: 4) seems to show that in the case recorded in the Baraita he does not accept the bererah principle, whereas in the case recorded in the Mishnah he accepts it. Thus R. Judah seems to contradict himself. But the case in the Baraita is one in which the final specification depends on the person himself, whereas in the case of the Mishnah it depends on others. This shows the correctness of Abbaye's distinction and refutes Rava.
Where the attempted proof is from a Tannaitic source two moves are open to the contestant who wishes to engage in refutation. He can either demonstrate that an alternative interpretation is possible, or, perhaps, necessary, or he can adduce another Tannaitic source which disagrees with the one quoted by his opponent and on which he can now rely. This is based on the generally accepted view, at least by the later Amoraim, that an Amora cannot disagree with a Tanna unless he can find support for so doing in the opinions of another Tanna.
Tenenblatt's The Formation of the Babylonian Talmud (in Hebrew, Tel-Aviv, 1972), chapter 15, pp. 276-94. Tenenblatt's work is an admirable summary of all the views on our question, relying heavily on the very fine study by Julius Kaplan, The Redaction of the Babylonian Talmud (New York, 1933). Tenenblatt refers to the work of S. M. Rubinstein, le-Heker Siddur ha-Talmud (Kovno, 1932), a work which I have not been able to consult but which is extensively quoted by Tenenblatt (chapter 5, pp. 81-111).
The Talmudic Argument: A Study in Talmudic Reasoning and Methodology by Louis Jacobs
by Robert
4.1